DTF Printing vs. Screen Printing: Which Is Better?

Written by Procolored - Published on Feb 6, 2025

9 minutes read

Written by Procolored - Published on June 5, 2025

Table of Content

1. What is The Difference Between DTF VS. Screen Printing
Understanding Each Contender
A. DTF (Direct-to-Film) – The New-School Maverick
B. Screen Printing – The Old-School Powerhouse
2. The Process – Behind the Magic
How DFT Works
How Screen Printing Works

3. DTF vs. Screen Printing: Who Wins Where?

Image Quality & Detail
Fabric Friendliness
Speed & Flexibility
Feel & Finish
Durability

4. Environmental Impact – Who’s Greener?

DTF: Cleaner Setup, But Not Waste-Free
Screen Printing: Traditional Process with a Footprint
5. Pros & Cons (Recap)
6. Who Should Use What?
DTF Is Great For Your Business If You…
Screen Printing Is Your Weapon If You…
7. The Verdict – No One-Size-Fits-All Winner
8. Final Words – Choose Your Weapon

Title

What if I told you your T-shirt’s life story started with a powder, a film, or a screen soaked in ink? In the world of apparel, two giants of printing, Screen printing and Direct-to-Film (DTF), go hand-in-hand in a battle for dominance.: DTF thrives for precise details and versatility while screen printing excels in bold colors and resilient prints.

If you’re starting a streetwear business, designing custom merchandise, or are even an enthusiast of printing technology; knowing this difference between screen print and dtf is crucial. Because in the printing world, the method you choose determines your style, budget, and overall success.

So, Let the print battle begin.

Understanding Each Contender

A. DTF (Direct-to-Film) – The Modern All-Rounder

Imagine printing a shirt as easily as slapping on a sticker—except this "sticker" is packed with eye-popping color, insane detail, and the power to stick to almost anything. That’s DTF printer for shirts—the rule-breaking newcomer that’s flipping the game on its head..

It is a revolutionary method that is shaking up the industry because it requires no screens. Just print your design on film, sprinkle some magic adhesive powder, and heat press it– your shirt is a walking masterpiece. Photorealistic artwork? A rainbow explosion of hues? A tiny, intricate logo? DTF is capable.

Moreover, it plays nice with cotton, leather, denim, or blends of polyester. So, If you want speed, versatility, and zero limits on creativity, DTF transfer printer is your wildcard.

B. Screen Printing – The Old-School Powerhouse

Now step into screen printing–the long time champion of custom apparel, and with good reason. It’s unrivaled in creating merchandise that endures the test of time. This classic method turned numerous blank tees into iconic merch for decades and is not planning to go anywhere.

So, how does it work? The screen printing pushes ink through a mesh screen, one layer at a time, and it’s as good as industrial-strength stenciling. The biggest advantage is that the prints last. Yes, setting up for designs with multiple colors takes time, but the end result – a well-printed, long-lasting shirt – is worth it.

Do you plan to print a bold logo on 200 sports team shirts? Grab a dtf screen printing machine.

The Process – Behind the Magic

How DTF Works?

DTF, short for Direct-to-Film, is all about making things colorful and straightforward. Here's how it works in simple steps

You print your design on a special film → sprinkle powder on it → use a heat press → and just like that, it’s on the fabric!

This process is similar to using a temporary tattoo, but way cooler because the print is bright and everlasting. The best part is you don’t have to worry about fabric type- it can be cotton, denim, polyester, or even leather, making DTF suitable for almost anything.

DTF is capable of handling intricate and colorful designs. More importantly, the flexibility it provides is unmatched.

How Screen Printing Works?

Screen printing is still one of the most cherished methods despite being more old school. It does take a longer amount of time, but is the best option when placed in bulk orders.

Here’s how it goes: You make your design → separate the colors → create a mesh screen for each color almost like a cutout→ use ink and a squeegee to push the design onto the fabric.

That might sound chaotic—and it is sometimes—but the end result is incredibly rewarding. Once your screens are set up, you can print dozens or even hundreds of shirts quickly.

Screen prints are known for being bold, vibrant, and long-lasting, which is why this method is still the go-to choice for things like team uniforms, event merch, or brand logo tees.

DTF vs. Screen Printing: Who Wins Where?

Image Quality & Detail

●DTF: Out of all printing methods, DTF printer is great with capturing intricate details, vivid colors, and reproducing photographs. You don’t have to worry about gradients, and tiny text because DTF can take care of that as well. Hence, for printing photographs, full-color illustrations, or designs with multiple layers of shading, DTF printing is the best option.

●Screen Printing: It’s great for large, striking images, but small intricate details and gradients are not its forte. Best suited is simple corporate logos, block colors, and clean shapes.

✅ Winner for detail and color complexity: DTF (Check: Procolored K8)

Fabric Friendliness

●DTF: One of the biggest advantages of DTF printing is that it can be done on various fabrics. It literally does not care whether you are working with cotton, polyester blends, denim, or even leather; DTF printers can adhere well to practically anything which is great if you’re printing across different types of products.

●Screen Printing: They give the best results on cotton or cotton blend fabrics. It can be done on other materials too, but you will need special inks, which means additional costs and more work beforehand.

✅ Winner for fabric variety: DTF

Speed & Flexibility

●DTF: DTF is the kind of process that is easy to set up and ready to go. It is ideal for short runs, last minute orders, or one-off designs due to the absence of screens and lengthy preparation time. DTF printing gives the ability to customize 10 shirts with different names with ease.

●Screen Printing: Each color of the design requires a separate screen which complicates the setup. A considerable amount of time will be consumed in this step, however once completed, it becomes really easy to print hundreds or thousands of items which is beneficial for bulk orders.

✅ Best for short runs and custom orders: DTF
✅ Best for large volume printing: Screen Printing

Feel & Finish

●DTF: The print on the fabric results in a soft and rubbery texture.The feel is more noticeable in larger prints, and some people do notice it.

●Screen Printing: When done correctly, the ink is absorbed by the fabric and not only works as a print but allows the shirt to breathe freely. Special care is needed while using water based or discharge inks, but when done right it can result in a soft and comfortable finish.

✅ Best for soft, natural feel: Screen Printing

Durability

●DTF: Under normal use, it can hold up well, but over time, especially with stretching or frequent washing, cracks and peeling may form on high-stress areas of the fabric.

●Screen Printing: This is where screen printing really shines.. The prints can be resistant to fading, and tough to damage, as well as endure a lot of wear and tear when completed with plastisol inks. The prints will outlast many washes and encourage plenty of heavy wear.

✅ Best for long-term durability: Screen Printing

Environmental Impact – Who’s Greener?

When it comes to printing methods, cost and quality aren’t the only things that must come into account. It’s also worth thinking about how eco-friendly each process is and which one is better for the planet.

DTF: Cleaner Setup, But Not Waste-Free

This technique saves on water, as no screen cleaning is required, making it less messy. However, commercial DTF printing has some of its own environmental impact. This printing method uses plastic PET film for transfers which creates non-recyclable waste after single use. Additionally, there is the use of powder adhesive and heat which require energy.

Thus, although Commercial DTF may look cleaner on the surface, the waste created from plastic and energy consumption, particularly at high volumes, remains a troubling issue.

Screen Printing: Traditional Process with a Footprint

This is one of the oldest printing techniques and like all old school methods, it is not very friendly to the environment. Screen printing is traditionally known for using a lot of water, especially during the cleaning of screens and equipment. The modern type ink used also contains corrosive solvents which can have detrimental impact to the environment.

Fortunately, the world is not static. Many screen printing shops are now shifting to eco-friendly water based inks and some are working to improve water reduction with filtration systems and greener chemicals. While the practices involved with screen printing can be resource intensive, it is optimizing with right practices.

Pros & Cons (Recap)

Feature

Setup Time

Detail & Color

Fabric Types

Ideal Order Size

Durability

DTF

Low

Excellent (photos, gradients)

Versatile

1–50 shirts

Good

Screen Printing

High

Great (bold, simple graphics)

Mostly cotton & blends

50+ shirts

Excellent

Who Should Use What?

Still not certain which printing option works best for your needs? Let's analyze it according to your style and preferences. It does not matter if you are at the beginning phases of your brand or you are already established; this choice will make a difference.

DTF Is Great For Your Business If You…

●🧢 You’re A Startup Or Testing The Market
If you are working on a smaller scale, the DTF printer for small business allows you to print a small number of items without worrying about high setup costs. You can try out designs, modify and test and test–perfect for early-stage brand

●🎨 Provide Custom/One-Off Designs
Want to put different names on 10 shirts or artwork on each hoodie? DTF transfer printer lets you print on demand and personalize each garment.

●🧵 Print On Fabrics That Are Considered Tricky To Use.
DTF doesn’t mind working with leather, nylon, denim, or blends. You will be pleased if you are expanding beyond cotton tees, as it works well on nearly any fabric.

Screen Printing Is Your Weapon If You…

●📦 You Require A Bulk Order
Need 500 shirts with the same bold design? Not an issue. As soon as the setup is finished, it can consistently deliver high quality while powering through large orders.

●🧼 You Need Prints That Last
The durability of screen printed designs is undeniable. With the appropriate inks, they can withstand years of washing, stretching, and even daily use without cracking or fading.

●🖌️ You Appreciate The Art Of Printmaking.
Screen Printing offers numerous opportunities for practices utilizing blending of inks, photo emulsion, burning images on screens, mixing ink, burning images on screens are but a few of the steps in all printmaking

The Verdict – No One-Size-Fits-All Winner

So, is DTF printing better than screen printing? Honestly, it depends.

There isn’t a clear winner here because each method has its own unique advantages. In the end, it comes down to what your business goals are, along with how you envision your business running.

●If you’re running a lean operation, doing some design experiments, or offering on-demand personalized merchandise, the best DTF transfer printer for small business lets you move fast and print on nearly any material.

●On the other hand, if you prefer consistency and strong, bold designs along with high-volume printing, screen printing will become your workhorse - strong, steady, and built for long-term durability.

Many successful apparel brands and print shops don’t choose one or the other. They rely on DTF printing machines for custom orders that have quick-turnaround times, or for very detailed designs, and reserve screen printing for their standard products and high-volume work.

Final Words – Choose Your Weapon

In the ongoing fight between DTF and screen printing, let's be honest - there is no universal winner. If there was a winner, it would be YOU, but only if your choice aligns with the real needs of your brand rather than what seems trendy.

Perhaps you appreciate all the precision and versatility DTF transfer printer offers . Or, it could very well be that you are enamored with the powerful impact and long-lasting effects of screen printing. The most important thing is that the method fits the objective, whether it’s custom one-of-a-kind pieces, bulk merchandise, or anything in the middle.

Here’s a brilliant Decision: Do not settle on one. We recommend trying a couple of designs with DTF (most likely Procolored P13) and then bulk screen printing the rest. From there you will better gauge what works for the products, your customers, and your workflow.

Having foresight on which printing method to select means your approach is intentional and pre-calculated. This way, your brand will not just print better, but will truly carve a name for itself.

To join our mailing list

and never miss our updates !